ARCHIVE
  • What is ARCHIVE?
  • The ACSA
  • The Schools
  • The Hive Wall

ARCHIVE

Second Responder

  • •••••
    We Are Second Responders
  • •••
    All Together Now: The Power of Many
  • •••
    Program: Making Purposeful Places for People
  • ••••••
    A Re(New)ed Orleans
  • Volunteerism: Architecture Gives Back
  • ••
    The Design and Drama of Studio Culture
  • ••
    VIDEO: The Reality, What Might Surprise You...
  • Where Do You Stand? Architecture Gets Political
  • ••
    Where'd That Building Go? Anywhere! It's Mobile
  • ••••
    The Place You Call Home
  • ••••
    Space for Everybody: Community Projects
  • ••
    United We Stand: Working in the Community
  • ••
    Haiti: Earthquakes Don't Hurt People, Buildings Do
  • •••••
    Do All Architecture Students Become Architects? Ask These People

Being Resourceful

  • •••••
    Architecture Is Being Resourceful
  • ••••••
    Water Water Everywhere, and Lots of Drops to Design
  • ••••••
    Transportation: Designing How We Get Around
  • ••••••
    Structuring Architecture
  • •••••
    Recycling: Material & Architectural Preservation
  • •••••
    The Solar Decathlon: A New Olympic Sport? Even Better!
  • ••••
    Digital Nation: Invisible Architecture
  • •••••••
    Ain't No Building High Enough
  • •••••
    Truly Sustaining Architecture: A Place for Food
  • •••
    Full Of Energy! Or Not
  • ••
    We Haven't Forgotten: Earthwork
  • •••••
    Think...Design-Build...Enjoy!
  • •••••
    Exploring Cities
  • ••
    VIDEO: A Day In The Life of an Architecture Student

Beauty Pageant

  • ••••
    A Pageant of Beauty, Brains, & Talent
  • ••
    Slicing Architecture: Making 2D From 3D
  • ••••
    Push A Button, Get A House? The Tools of Digitalia
  • ••••
    Cinematic Space: Architecture and the Moving Image
  • •
    Space... the Final Frontier
  • •••
    Yes, Sometimes Beauty Is Skin Deep
  • •••
    Process Before Product: From Ideas to Architecture
  • ••
    The Mother Art: Breadth In Architectural Study
  • ••••
    Nerd It Up! Architects Dig Math
  • ••••
    Land-scapes
  • ••
    Milling Around With Robots: Fabrication
  • •
    Getting Going: Ideas & Inspirations
  • ••••
    Start it Up: Making Jobs, Not Getting Them
  • CON-TEM-PO-RAR-Y Is So Chic, So Now
  • •
    VIDEO: The Definition, What Is An Architect?

Architecture Culture

  • •••
    A Culture All Its Own
  • •
    I'll Tumblr for Ya: Meming, Networky & Bloggerific
  • ••••
    A Model Adventure
  • ••
    VIDEO: The Call, When Did Architecture Capture You?
  • •
    Blueprints & T-Squares: Outdated Icons And Stereotypes
  • ••••••
    Am I An Architect Yet? The Internship
  • •••
    Anything You Can Do I Can Do Better: Diversity In Architecture
  • ••••••••
    Hey, I Heard Architecture Graduates Can't Get Jobs
  • ••••
    Kickstart Me! School Before School
  • ••
    The Review: Putting Yourself Out There
  • ••••
    Can I Only Design Buildings? Profiles in Aligned Professions
  • ••••
    Get Outta Here: Field Tripping and Study Abroad
  • •••••
    Say What? Talking Like A Human
  • ••••••••
    Student life: The Pain, Stress, and Time-Management Issues!
  • ••
    Event Spaces: What Happens Outside Of Class

Wild Card

  • •••••••
    In the Wildcard: Architects of Other Things
  • •••••
    George Takei, funniest guy on facebook
  • •••
    Catherine Hardwicke, Immortalized Director
  • ••••
    Saad Chehab, driving force at Chrysler…
  • ••••
    Aishwarya Rai, Miss World!
  • •••••••
    Joseph Kosinski, technologist
  • ••••
    MC Ice Cube, M.C. Escher
  • •••
    Tom Ford, Gucci
  • •••
    Andrew Luck, rookie of the year?
  • •••
    Martha Stewart, Inc.
  • ••••••••••••••••••••••••••
    Courteney Cox, friend of architecture
  • ••••••••••
    Roger Waters - We don't need no education?
  • •••••
    Evan Sharp, God of Pinterest
  • ••••••
    VIDEO: The Exhibit, What is ARCHIVE?
  • •••
    Questions? Comments? This is Your Space

Second Responder

Second Responder

Being Resourceful

Being Resourceful

Beauty Pageant

Beauty Pageant

Architecture Culture

Architecture Culture

Wild Card

Wild Card
   

The Review: Putting Yourself Out There

  • Thesis Review Week at the Southern California Institute of Architecture
  • Being Reviewed at Cornell University
  • Being Reviewed at the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
  • Being Reviewed at the University of Southern California
  • Being Reviewed at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln
  • Being Reviewed at the University of Tennessee-Knoxville
  • Presentation to Providence Planning Director & Stakeholders

PreviousNext

     
     

    How do architects get big egos? They endure one of the many rights of passage in architecture school: surviving reviews.

    Architecture students learn how to design by taking semester-long studios where they're given complex design projects to develop with the help of their professor. During this process, faculty provide feedback on their progress through one-on-one in-class critiques called DESK CRITS but, several times a semester, they must also present their work to the class as a whole and be judged by a jury of experts, typically other faculty or professional architects. These more formal reviews, called mid-reviews or final reviews depending on when they occur, are attended by other students, faculty, and even the general public. Students in one studio hang or project their work in a designated area; then, over many hours, each student presents to the panel who asks questions and gives immediate feedback on the process, outcome, and implications of the work.

    And, as anyone who has been through this process can tell you, jurors are not shy! They commonly give intense criticism or glowing praise. Most juries make their comments constructive so that students learn how to improve their design skills; in the best cases, jurors may not actually refer to the quality of the work, but instead just discuss what it means. Still, this is a hard process for many beginning students because, after working really hard in preparation, they often take disappointing comments personally. After participating in reviews over many years — often 10 to 20 times before graduating — students learn how to better present their work, answer questions, think on their feet, and remain calm in the face of tough feedback. It is not uncommon to have sleepy or bumbling students in attendance after weeks of late nights finishing their work and argumentative or emotional students not yet adapted to taking criticism in a professional way.

    This process is important in preparing students for similar experiences in practice, where they'll be presenting their work to clients, peers, neighborhood groups, or public commissions. Learning how to listen and respond is as important as how to speak. And if all else fails, in those tired, stressed-out moments, it might not hurt to make sure the jury is well fed and full of coffee...

    Thesis Review Week at the Southern California Institute of Architecture
    Southern California Institute of Architecture
    Being Reviewed at Cornell University
    Cornell University
    Fall 2011
    Being Reviewed at the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
    Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
    Design Reviews
    Being Reviewed at the University of Southern California
    Blue Tape
    Orhan Ayyüce
    Spring 2011
    Being Reviewed at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln
    University of Nebraska-Lincoln
    ARCH 511: "Destination: NEW YORK"
    Chris Ford
    Spring 2009
    Jamison Burt
    Being Reviewed at the University of Tennessee-Knoxville
    University of Tennessee-Knoxville
    Advanced Studio
    Andrew Thurlow
    Spring 2004
    Presentation to Providence Planning Director & Stakeholders
    Rhode Island School of Design
    Advanced Design Studio
    Maia Small and Enrique Martinez
    Spring 2006
    Alex Bilotti, Amanda Gearey, Brandon Massey, Frank Ching, Matthew Turk, Lan Zhong, Stephanie Smith, Yu Ding, Sebastian Snyder

    ARCHIVE is an Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture project in celebration of its 100 year anniversary - for more visit: www.acsa100.org.

    Copyright © 2013